Andrew Arkin (1924-2009) discovered Taylor's Island while flying over Coecles Harbor in a seaplane. Through a realtor, Greg Price, Andrew was able to contact Mr. Taylor's nephew, Stephan Stephano, who had the lifetime use of the Island. Andrew was able to lease the Island in exchange for the maintenance and restoration of the cabin, as well as providing access to Mr. Taylor's sister should she wish to visit her brother's grave. Andrew was able to care for Taylor's Island for twenty-two years, until 1980. Andrew returned to Taylor's Island in 2006. In 2008 he arrived by seaplane, for a celebration in his honor.